THE INTEL BRIEF

News and Content From Our Members





Menu
Log in

Log in
FR

Book Review: A Forever War by Colin Shindler

March 07, 2026 1:58 PM | Anonymous

A FOREVER WAR: ISRAEL, PALESTINE AND THE STRUGGLES FOR STATEHOOD

BY COLIN SHINDLER
FEBRUARY 26, 2026
PUBLISHER: SWIFT PRESS



 A Forever War: Israel, Palestine and the struggles for statehood

by Colin Shindler
 
For over a century, the Middle East has been riven by conflict driven by Jewish and Arab nationalism. They came about at the same point in history with claims over the same territory. 

Their encounter has evolved into one of the most enduring and divisive geopolitical issues of the modern era – one defined by its complexity and its extremism and unfolding against a backdrop of 24-hour rolling news and social-media outrage. A Forever War: Israel, Palestine and the Struggles for Statehood reflects on the key questions: How did this state of affairs come about? And will it be a forever war?

At a time when so much coverage is based on prejudice, fear and ignorance, Colin Shindler, Emeritus Professor of Israel Studies at SOAS, presents an authoritative view of this tragic conflict and dissects the current situation. Tracing the religious, political and historical motivations of both sides throughout many decades of turmoil and upheaval, A Forever War is the concise and non-partisan overview of the conflict that is so sorely needed. 

Indigo Amazon 



 “[What emerges from this synthesis is neither cynicism nor naïveté. Shindler believes partition remains the least bad path, and he makes that case by showing how every non‑partition experiment—unilateralism, strategic ambiguity, managed stalemate—has tended to strengthen the rejectionists who thrive on absolutes..”― Jean-Thomas Nicole - Policy Advisor with Public Safety Canada.

The Preface says that the book is ‘intended as a contribution towards understanding the complex background to this hundred-year war’ yet there is no discussion of the nature of the Occupation which has been at the heart of the Israel-Palestine struggle since 1967. Shindler acknowledges the illegality, under the Geneva Convention, of Israeli settlements but there is no recognition of what might be achieved by the implementation of international law nor of any possible role which the United Nations might have in ending this ‘Forever War’. - Mike Scott-Baumann - Trustee of the Britain Palestine Project.


See also:

A Forever War as reviewed by Jean-Thomas Nicole for The Cipher Brief  – February 23, 2026



 

Photo: Shutterstock.

About the book: 
A Forever War: Israel, Palestine and the struggles for statehood
by Colin Shindler
Swift Press – 256 pages $17.99 (Kindle)
Publication Date: February 26, 2026
 



About the Author: Emma Ashford

Colin Shindler is emeritus professor at the School of Oriental and African Studies (SOAS), University of London. He became the first professor of Israel Studies in the UK  in 2008 and was the founding chairman of the European Association of Israeli Studies (EAIS) in 2009.

He is the author of numerous books including his History Of Modern Israel (Cambridge University Press 2008, 2013).

The History of Modern Israel has been translated into Italian, Polish and Estonian.

His main interests lie in the evolution of the Israeli Right, the changes in the approach of the British and European Left towards Israel since 1948 and the emigration movement of Soviet Jews between 1917 and 1991.

He worked for the British campaign for Soviet Jewry between 1968 and 1977 – and edited the weekly Jews in the USSR between 1972 and 1975. His first book, published in 1978, was Exit Visa which detailed the struggle of the Jewish emigration movement in the USSR.

He was the co-chairman of the Universities Committee for Soviet Jewry between 1970 and 1971 and political secretary of the World Union of Jewish Students between 1970 and 1971. He edited the Jewish Quarterly between 1985 and 1994. He edited Judaism Today between 1995 and 1998.

He lectures and broadcasts nationally and internationally. He has written for and reviewed for The TimesGuardian, New York Times, Plus61j, Jewish IndependentJewish News, Jewish Chronicle, Jerusalem Post, Ha’aretz, History Today, Times Literary Supplement, New Statesman and many other journals. The author of over 800 articles and reviews since 1969 on Israel and Jewish political history – all of which can be located on this website.

He is currently honorary president of the EAIS.


Book Review / Revue de livres 

Disclaimer: Articles are chosen for relevance and circulated for information only. Views expressed are those of the respective journalists / authors. Republication does not infer endorsement.

Book Review Editor: Ralph Mahar - Suggestions for Book Reviews will be gratefully received at 
thepillarsociety.bulletins@gmail.com


Author
Comment
 

The Pillar Society Privacy Policy and Terms of Service | © Copyright 2025 The Pillar Society | All Rights Reserved